
The Northern Territory government wants to make pepper spray available to 16 and 17-year-olds. Its answer to parents worried about their children’s safety is to let them purchase a weapon.
Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro has announced plans to permanently legalise pepper spray following a twelve-month trial, with legislation expected by the end of the year. The proposed changes would extend access to teenagers with a guardian’s consent, broaden its use by hospitality workers and allow eligible household members to use spray purchased by someone else.
This announcement belongs within a much larger political project. Across Australia, governments are expanding police powers to search people, declaring public spaces subject to exceptional policing powers and increasing the visibility of heavily armed officers. People are encouraged to fear one another, accept greater surveillance and understand weapons as the foundation of safety.
The result is a dangerous proposition: we will become safer by becoming more armed, more suspicious and more willing to submit to police control.
When selling weapons becomes a measure of success
Finocchiaro described the pepper spray trial as having a “99 per cent success rate”, referring to legal purchases. However, a weapon being purchased legally tells us little about whether its availability has reduced violence.
Where is the publicly scrutinised evidence about injuries prevented, escalation, misuse, accidental exposure or weapons being taken from the people carrying them? Where is the assessment of what happens when pepper spray enters households where coercion and violence already exist?
Police have pointed to an incident in which legally purchased spray reportedly prevented domestic violence. That matters to the person involved. It does not, by itself, establish that expanding access across the population is effective violence prevention.
People facing violence deserve options. Nobody should have to pass an ideological test before defending themselves. But an individual surviving an immediate threat and a government building its safety policy around weapon ownership are different questions.
The government cannot answer demands for safety by transferring responsibility onto the person at risk, then declaring success because the product sold.
Children deserve somewhere safe to go
Finocchiaro’s argument that sixteen-year-olds can drive and work does little to establish whether expanding access to pepper spray will make them safer. Driving and employment involve responsibilities, but neither provides evidence about the consequences of introducing another weapon into young people’s lives.
Teachers’ concerns about spray entering schools are reasonable. Giving school staff authority to confiscate it acknowledges that possibility while leaving them to manage the consequences.
Yet the critique should also resist portraying teenagers as inherently reckless or untrustworthy. Young people experience violence. Some travel home from late shifts. Some live with abuse. Some have good reason to fear encounters with adults, including adults in authority. Telling them to reconsider where they go or what time they leave can slide into the same restrictive logic routinely imposed on women: organise your life around the threat of somebody else’s violence.
Young people deserve freedom of movement and safety. That requires safe transport, secure housing, trusted adults, accessible support and places they can go without being harassed or criminalised. Handing them a canister leaves those obligations unresolved.
What happens when the threat wears a uniform?
The NT government’s promise of self-defence leaves a fundamental question unanswered: what happens when the young person’s fear is an authority? The policy imagines a threatening stranger and a person entitled to protect themselves. It has little to say about violence, intimidation or abuse by someone wearing a uniform.
Imagine a frightened sixteen-year-old reaching for pepper spray during an encounter with an armed officer. The government may have authorised them to carry it for protection, but that does not mean the officer will recognise their actions as self-defence. The child could be treated as an armed threat. An encounter could escalate to lethal force. A child could be shot while reaching for the very weapon the government told them would make them safer.
This is a foreseeable risk that demands scrutiny, not a claim that every encounter will end this way. What assessment has the government made of it? What protection does its promise offer a young person who fears state violence?
That question becomes more urgent as the Territory brings firearms into the places people depend on every day. On 29 June 2026, the first Police Public Safety Officers began operating, including on the bus network and at public housing estates. The new armed policing stream is replacing roles previously performed by transit safety officers, public housing safety officers and police auxiliaries. This is a restructuring of transport and housing safety around armed police intervention.
A bus is how a teenager gets to school, work or a friend’s house. Public housing is somebody’s home. Bringing guns into these settings makes armed authority part of the ordinary experience of travelling and living. People cannot simply avoid these encounters without potentially giving up access to transport or withdrawing from the spaces around their own homes.
For a young person who experiences an officer’s conduct as threatening, the contradiction is stark: the government encourages them to carry a weapon for protection while expanding the presence of armed authorities whose response to that weapon could put their life at risk.
The government cannot assume that every uniform represents safety to every person. Nor can it promote self-defence without confronting whose fear will be believed, whose actions will be recognised as protective and whose actions will be used to justify force against them.
A safety policy must account for the possibility that the state itself causes harm. Otherwise, it offers protection only within a story where authorities are always the protectors and the people they police are always the potential threat.
Searching for weapons while expanding access to them
Alongside this push to broaden access to pepper spray, governments are using concern about knives to expand police intervention in everyday life.
In the NT, police describe sixteen high-risk areas where authorised wanding operations can subject anyone in the area to screening. These include town centres, neighbourhood precincts and the Nightcliff foreshore.
In South Australia, shopping centres and parts of Adelaide have been declared public precincts. Police have explicitly said they do not require suspicion to wand someone within these areas. The declarations also provide powers to order people to leave.
Queensland’s new Designated Business and Community Precinct in Maryborough similarly combines weapons searches with move-on directions and banning notices. Breaching those directions becomes a criminal offence.
The legal names and details differ between jurisdictions. The political direction is familiar: ordinary public space becomes a place where your presence can be checked, questioned and prohibited.
Concern about a weapon becomes justification for powers extending beyond finding that weapon. Shopping, gathering or spending time in a town centre increasingly takes place on terms set by police.
A useful analysis would ask who bears that intrusion. Who is treated as a shopper, and who is treated as a problem? Whose presence reassures business owners, and whose presence attracts a direction to leave?
For Aboriginal people, criminalised young people and people living without secure housing, an expansion of discretionary policing cannot simply be accepted as a universal promise of protection.
Rifles are entering the picture too
In NSW, the government has unveiled a permanent Armed Response Command backed by $94.3 million. At full strength, it is intended to have 250 officers and 28 civilian staff. Officers will have access to the Australian Combat Assault Rifle, and the government has told the public to expect rifles and specialist vehicles on Sydney streets as training moves into public settings. The command’s role includes patrolling high-risk areas and providing a presence at places of worship and major events.
Responding to an immediate armed attack and establishing a permanent, highly visible armed presence across community life require separate scrutiny. The possibility of a horrific incident should not end discussion about what powers, equipment and practices become normal afterwards.
The government describes this presence as reassurance. Reassurance for whom?
The sight of an officer carrying a combat rifle produces fear in many regular citizens, let alone for people whose experience of police includes racism, intimidation or violence. An account of community safety that cannot recognise fear of the state is already excluding a large part of the community.
Police weapons must remain within the frame when governments discuss weapons in our streets. A uniform does not remove a weapon’s capacity to injure or kill.
The deserving right to protection
The NT trial required purchasers to declare that they had no relevant criminal history or police or court orders. The proposed teenage access would remain conditional on meeting eligibility requirements.
That raises another question: whose fear qualifies for recognition?
Criminalised people experience violence too. Women with criminal records may also be survivors of abuse. A record cannot be treated as a straightforward dividing line between people needing protection and people posing a threat.
The policy’s eligibility rules require scrutiny for precisely this reason. Governments repeatedly divide communities into those entitled to safety and those whose exclusion is supposed to deliver it.
That division allows the violence experienced by criminalised people to disappear from view, even while their presence is invoked to justify more weapons and police powers.
Safety requires a different political commitment
A sensible response must take people’s fear seriously without allowing governments to turn that fear into an endless mandate for force.
Safety requires secure housing and enough income to live. It requires Aboriginal community-controlled responses, youth spaces, safe transport, non-carceral crisis support and practical help for people escaping violence. It also requires sustained work with people causing harm, rather than waiting for another emergency and offering another weapon.
These are immediate responsibilities. They cannot be deferred while governments expand searches, exclusions and armed patrols.
A teenager should be able to get home from work safely. A woman should have somewhere secure to go when she leaves an abusive partner. Aboriginal people should be able to occupy public space without their presence being treated as a threat.
Governments are teaching us to accept a society in which safety means carrying a weapon, submitting to a search or standing beneath the watch of an officer with an assault rifle.
We should refuse that political horizon. Our communities deserve the material conditions to live safely together, and the power to build them.
